Sunday 29 December 2019

Don’t Be Unreasonable Student of Knowledge


Giyaath Ibn Ibraaheem[1] used to feign knowledge and claim that he has memorized Ahaadeeth and would narrate them. He was eminent and eloquent. The people used to sit around him and he would narrate amazing things to them which they believed.

One day, a man saw him doing something inappropriate and said to him: “Are you not shy of the people?” He replied: “Where are the people?” He said: “Those people who gather around you.” He said: “You mean those people; those people are not human being, they are cattle. If you want me to prove it to you, come with me.”

Then both of them went and Giyaath sat in his assembly and began to narrate to the people about Paradise and its description while they listened attentively.

When he noticed their attentiveness to his narrations, he fabricated a hadeeth from his intellect: “The Messenger of Allah (sallallaahu alayhi wasallam) said: “Whoever among you who can touch the tip of his nose with his tongue will enter Paradise.”

So the people immediately began to bring out their tongues, trying to touch the tip of their nose with it. Then Giyaath turned to his friend and said to him: “Did I not tell you that they are cattle?!”

Source: Searching For a Job? p. 106-107 by Dr. Muhammad al-Areefi, translated by this writer.




[1] He was a liar and fabricator of hadeeth. Aboo Haatim stated about him in his book, al-Majrooheen: “He used to fabricate amazing narration “He used to fabricate amazing narrations ascribing them to reliable narrators.”

No comments:

Post a Comment