Wednesday 20 April 2016

Ways of Praying Maghrib Behind the Imam Praying Ishaa’



Question: A man entered the mosque in order to perform Ishaa’ prayer, then he remembered that he has not prayed Maghrib. What should he do?

Response: When you enter the mosque while Ishaa’ prayer is being observed, then you recalled that you have not prayed Maghrib, join the congregation with the intention of performing Maghrib prayer; and when the Imam stands for the fourth rak’ah, sit down for your third rak’ah and wait for the Imam [till he completes his fourth rak’ah]. Then, you should terminate the prayer along with him. You may also terminate your prayer [alone] and thereafter join the Imam in whatever is left of the Ishaa’ prayer.[1]

The difference of intention between the Imam and the one praying behind the Imam does not matter according to the correct view among the sayings of the people of knowledge. And if you perform the Maghrib prayer alone, and after that join the congregation in observing whatever is left of the Ishaa’ prayer, there is no harm.

Source: Fataawaa Arkaan al-Islaam, p. 197, by Shaykh Muhammad bin Saalih al-Uthaymeen (may Allah have mercy on him)



Question: A man enters the masjid when the ‘Ishaa prayer has been called to commence. However, he has not prayed the Maghrib prayer, due to a legitimate reason. What should he do in this case?

Answer: This man should follow the Imaam that is leading the ‘Ishaa prayer, while having the intention for praying the Maghrib prayer. But when the Imaam rises for the fourth raka’ah, he should intend to separate himself from the Imaam and then (continue) sitting, make the tashahhud and finish his prayer alone.

Source: The Fataawaa of Shaikh al-Albaanee from al-Asaalah Magazine Issues 1-21, p.35


[1] Shaykh al-Uthaymeen (may Allah have mercy on him) expressed his preference for this method in Sharh al-Mumti’, vol. 2, p. 184

No comments:

Post a Comment